Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Book Review: ENCHANTMENTS by Kathryn Harrison

How does a teenager process the fact that her beloved father’s murder signals the death knell of the world she’s known? What part of her old world can she take with her into the ominous new one? And who can she turn to for comfort when her lot in life is to comfort others? These would be difficult enough questions to tackle for any young woman – but for a daughter of the monk Rasputin, the personal turmoil reverberates throughout a country.

Kathryn Harrison’s Enchantments is a beautifully written story about the end of the Romanov dynasty, imagined from the point of view of an actual eyewitness: Matryona “Masha” Rasputina. Novels that present a well-known story from a new standpoint are certainly not uncommon. Still, there is something to be said for “pivoting the table” as my quantitative friends would say, and exploring a tale from a new or unique angle. Harrison uses the tsarina’s desperation at the loss of Rasputin to bring Masha inside the palace as a surrogate healer for her hemophiliac son, Tsarevich Alexander, which gives her narrative a unique insider/outsider perspective on the last days of the royal family – and a turbulent time in history.

The novel centers on the relationship between the tsarevich, known to his family as Aloysha, and Masha. Rasputin led the tsarina to believe that Masha shared his healing powers, but Masha is not convinced, and instead uses her true gift – story telling – to amuse the doomed young man while they wait for they know not what. Ironically, her stories give him an appreciation for a Russia that none of the other Romanovs ever bothered to know, which is the reason why he’ll never rule it.

Harrison’s writing is rich and evocative, as she describes the end of an era:

In the years before the Bolsheviks seized the city, St. Petersburg was a playground in the throes of a kind of decadence – determined, desperate – that presages collapse. As if the aristocracy knew apocalypse was imminent and, also knowing there was nothing to prevent its arrival, stayed up drinking and dancing and inhaling cocaine when they could get their hands on any, distracting themselves by whatever means they found. Spending money in a frenzy of champagne, caviar, jewels, gowns. On parties with full orchestras, themed costume balls excusing all manner of ostentation: hostesses riding through ballrooms on gilded elephants, servants dressed up like gondoliers or Vikings or pharaohs. p. 180
I loved Masha’s voice, but unfortunately the disjointed, asynchronous narrative was not as successful for me. The story jumps from Rasputin’s early life to the family’s time in St. Petersburg to Siberian folk wisdom to Masha’s exile from Russian rather incoherently at times, so that I often didn’t have a handle on the plot. I cared about the characters, but in fits and starts. I also found the “coming of age” portions of the book between Aloysha and Masha squirm-inducing. They seemed to belong more in a YA title than in this one – especially because they were accompanied by high-end philosophical thought on the nature of virtue and morality.

Still, the story was interesting and fast-paced, and it made me rethink what I knew about Rasputin and the Romanovs, so I would highly recommend it to lovers of historical fiction, especially those with an interest in imperial Russia. This title counts toward the Historical Fiction 2012 Challenge, which seems to be the only one I’m tearing up so far this year. Thanks to Historical Tapestry for hosting! I do have some additional books to review, though, so I’m hoping to start really making progress on my reading goals for the year!

I read this book as part of a TLC book tour, and received a copy of the book in return for my honest opinion. For other opinions, check out the links here.

In 140 characters or less:The beginning of adulthood and the end of the world from a Rasputin's perspective.

8 comments:

  1. Very nice review -- I loved this book and found the sort of dreamy narrative style appealing -- but I'm a sucker for that kind of thing.

    I too am tearing through my historical fiction reading challenge -- the only one I'm ever really successful with!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Audra. I think my current level of distraction, preparing for the trip to China/daughter's graduation/sabbatical may have contributed to my disorientation. But I really loved Harrison's writing!

      Delete
  2. I love historical fiction books set in Russia. This sounds very interesting!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't read a lot of Russian fiction, but this was great, and made me want to read more!

      Delete
  3. I love the premise of this - it sounds like it could have used a little more editing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did wish for a bit more logical flow to the narrative. But then Audra loved the book, so it may have just been me -- because Audra has never steered me wrong on a histfic title! So I think you'd know in the first 25 pages if the style was for you. But I think you'd find the writing beautiful in any case.

      Delete
  4. Intersting. I love this era and would have loved a great novel about it - think I'll pass on this one due to the execution. Too bad. Great revie, thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm glad that you enjoyed the story even if the narrative style didn't quite work for you. Thank for being on the tour

    ReplyDelete

I absolutely love comments. Thanks for taking the time to share! Col