Monday, February 27, 2012

Book Review: SONOMA ROSE by Jennifer Chiaverini

Normally, I am a person who hates to come into a book series in the middle. So I’m going to admit to being a little worried when Jennifer Chiaverini’s Sonoma Rose arrived and I saw the subtitle: An Elm Creek Quilts Novel. I had never heard of the series, so I went to visit the site and realized I was jumping into the middle of what appeared to be a cottage industry: novels, fabric patterns, even a cookbook, all inspired by Chiaverini’s work. There was no way to catch up (there are already 18 books in the series), so I just decided to jump in and hope for the best. I’m happy to say I was rewarded with a novel of depth and grit that brought a time and a place that I know very little about – Prohibition era California – to life.

The novel begins with Rosa Diaz Barclay trapped in a loveless and increasingly volatile marriage to John, desperate at having lost four of her 8 children to a mysterious wasting disease that attacked them right after they were weaned. Two of her four remaining children suffer from the same affliction, although the other two, including her eldest, are completely healthy. Having been abandoned by her family, her only support comes from her childhood sweetheart, Lars Jorgensen, and a new arrival in Arboles Valley, Elizabeth Nelson. When Elizabeth witnesses one of John’s jealous rages, the stage is set for Rosa to run. The family’s attempt to free themselves both from the tyranny of an abusive spouse and the nightmare of a disease that the local doctors cannot understand comprise the main action of the novel, and I was caught up in Rosa’s world from the very beginning.

This novel serves up a really interesting piece of historical fiction, and throws in a offbeat love story for good measure. Rosa and her family find themselves among the desperate northern California vineyard owners who are trying to hold onto their land and their heritage as Prohibition slowly destroys their way of life. I had never really thought about the unintended effects of Prohibition on law abiding citizens – and how desperation might have forced vineyard owners into relationships with criminals, just to keep their heads above water. The book emphasizes the ambiguity of the time by contrasting the slimy Prohibition agent, Dwight Crowell, with the protective bootlegger, Mr. Lucerno.

It was also fascinating to think about how much medicine has changed our lives in less than 100 years. In the time before genetic testing and antibiotics, illness must have seemed so much more mysterious and ominous than it does to us now. Rosa’s attempts to deal with her children’s condition were so heartbreaking that any mother reading could easily put herself in Rosa’s place.

While Sonoma Rose was identified as part of the Elm Creek Quilt series, quilts and quilt-making are only tangential to the storyline. From what I’ve read, this may make Sonoma Rose an unusual part of the collection, but for me it meant there was no problem understanding what was going. It’s possible that the heirloom quilts that Elizabeth gives Rosa are detailed in a previous book, but not knowing that didn’t detract in any way from my enjoyment of the book.

I’ve been reading a lot of translated fiction and classic fiction lately, and Sonoma Rose was a nice, light break. Not being a quilter, I’m not sure if I’d go back and read the rest of the series. But I did enjoy this novel very much, and recommend it to those interested in 20th century historical fiction, regardless of whether they are quilters or not. This book counts for the Historical Fiction Challenge 2012 – it’s about time I got something done, challenge-wise, to keep February from being a complete bust! Thanks to everyone at Historical Tapestry for hosting!

I read this book as part of a TLC book tour, and received a copy of the book in return for my honest opinion. For other opinions, check out the links here.

9 comments:

  1. It sounds like that series has lasted so long for good reason. I love to read about that time period.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's funny, Kathy, I haven't read a lot from this time period in the US at all, although I've read a lot of inter-war period fiction from the UK. I really enjoyed it!

      Delete
  2. Maybe if I was a mom I would have gotten more out of it. I loved reading your perspective on the book!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really did like the book, but I would also agree with you that it could have lost 50 pages and maybe been a tighter story. But it probably also helped me out, because I hadn't read any of the earlier books in the series.

      Delete
  3. This is a really interesting time period & it's amazing how much was affected by prohibition, for example the Scottish whisky industry, who originally made a lot of money, but to keep up with the demand the quality dropped to appalling levels, which for a long time after gave it a bad image & took it a long time to get away from.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It makes total sense, Parrish, and I'm surprised I haven't read more about it. Poor quality Scotch is just a sad thing -- glad that situation has been amended :)

      Delete
  4. Your review has me so relieved as I had a jaw drop moment when I saw how many books are part of the franchise! I'm thrilled knowledge of the previous books isn't necessary to enjoy this one!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The book really stands on its own, although I have to admit that I have no idea how it might fit in for people who have read the entire series. I am looking forward to hear what you think about this one, Audra!

      Delete
  5. I'm glad to know that I don't have to go back and read every book in the series in order to enjoy this one!

    Thanks for being on the tour.

    ReplyDelete

I absolutely love comments. Thanks for taking the time to share! Col